Hello dear
Welcome To Peppe's Pizza & Subs
Peppe's Pizza & Subs, located at 52 E Carey St in Wilkes-Barre, PA, is a beloved local eatery known for its nostalgic charm and mouthwatering offerings. Customers rave about the delightful Old Forge pizza, featuring a light, crispy crust and sweet sauce, crafted by the passionate owner, Joe. The menu also includes delectable subs, homemade soups, and crispy wings with tantalizing sauce options. Peppe's stands out for its commitment to quality ingredients and authentic flavors, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers. With an inviting atmosphere and exceptional service, Peppe's truly embodies the heart and soul of old-school dining.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Mozzarella Sticks (6)
US$5.00Wings
US$9.00Chicken
US$3.00
Cappelletti
US$3.00Chef Salad
US$6.50Antipasto
US$7.00
Tuna & Cheese (Lettuce & Tomato)
US$6.50Tuna & Cheese with Cheese (12")
US$7.00Eggplant Parmigiana Sub
US$6.50 About
Peppe's Pizza & Subs
Welcome to Peppe's Pizza & Subs, a cherished gem located at 52 E Carey St, Wilkes-Barre, PA. This unpretentious eatery is a beloved staple in the community, known primarily through word of mouth rather than social media hype. The magic here lies in the hands of owner Joe, who pours his heart and soul into every dish, creating an authentic dining experience that evokes nostalgia.
At Peppe's, the pizza is what truly steals the spotlight. Featuring a unique blend of Old Forge and Wilkes-Barre styles, the light and crispy crust pairs beautifully with a subtly sweet sauce and a robust cheese blend. It’s a combination that locals rave about—Kitty Caruthers shares how it’s "worth the drive" for Joe's extraordinary pizza, highlighting the sauce's distinctive touch that sets it apart and raises the standard for pizza aficionados.
The menu doesn't stop at pizza; you’ll also find irresistible wings and classic subs. Enjoy their crispy wings served with your choice of sauces—BBQ, Honey Mustard, Hot, Jack Daniels, or Mild—for just $9.00 a dozen. And don’t overlook the scrumptious Mozzarella Sticks and homemade soups, like the hearty Chicken or Cappelletti, both priced at just $3.00.
If you’re in the mood for a sandwich, the Parmigiana Subs are a must-try. Whether it’s the Eggplant or Chicken Parmigiana Sub at $6.50 and $7.00 respectively, they embody comfort and flavor, making each bite a delightful experience.
Customer reviews echo the sentiment of a community treasure. Joe’s commitment to quality and his old-school approach to service have left patrons like Jay W with unforgettable experiences that blend delicious food with a welcoming atmosphere. Kenneth Crake attests to Joe's culinary expertise, saying that every bite is full of flavor, reaffirming the dedication to quality that drives this establishment.
In conclusion, Peppe's Pizza & Subs is more than just a restaurant; it’s a warm embrace of flavor and nostalgia, perfect for anyone craving a genuine slice of the good life. As Joe continues to serve the community with heart, your visit promises more than just a meal—it’s a delicious journey back to the basics of comfort food. Come and experience the flavors that have earned Peppe’s its reputed place in the hearts of many!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Old school, no frills take out place. The Owner(Joe), doesn’t do social media, all word of mouth. The Old Forge Pizza is a cross with Wilkes-Barre. Light crispy crust(Old Forge) with a sweet sauce(Wilkes-Barre) and a solid cheese blend. ”
“ Best pizza place around! Used to live up the street from them and word order once a week. Now live 45 min away but still worth the drive for Joes amazing old forge pizza. Idk if its the sauce but something about his pizza really stands out and sets a high bar. Wings are amazing with a nice sauce and a little crispy. ”
“ What a great experience of wonderful people and food all together! Our food was top notch with NY style pizza coupled with a Calzone that was huge! Could not beat the prices either. As for the service...out of this world! Joe certainly knows how to keep it old school with heart & soul! Cheers Joe!!! Keep it going! ”
“ The NY pizza is best. Old Forge excellent! This guy Joe M can also lay it down like the real chef that he is. Every bit has a layer of flavor making the perfect bite. ”
“ Just had the round pie for the first time. Absolutely delicious!!!! Owner is very nice. Will definitely be back many times! ”
“ Went in for lunch yesterday, and I've gotta say: The pizza is amazing, like, perfect. The wings were 10/10, crispy, well sauced, just delightful. The mozzarella sticks were great too. My wife got a chicken cheesesteak, which I didn't try, but she said it was great. The service is great, the prices are reasonable, and the atmosphere is welcoming. I'll definitely be going back, if I could give them 6 stars, I would. ”
“ Food was amazing, tasted like the vegetables were right out of the garden. Will definitely go back. ”
“ Peppes Pizza Is Amazing People If You Want really Good Pizza Trust Me Me This Is The Place To Go Great Sauce Taste Everything On Point Subs Are Also Amazing & Don't Forget The Wings If You Say Red Bull Give You Wings Peppes Wings Gives You That Only Energy Wings Owner At Peppes Makes You Feel Like You At Home Peppes Is 5 Star General. ”